Experimenting with Barclay’s Formula and TRIAC

Gee argues that “true acquisition of many mainstream [dominant] Discourses involves, at least while being in them, active complicity with values that conflict with one’s home- and community-based Discourses, especially for many women and minorities” (13).  Delpit responds to Gee, countering that “acquiring the ability to function in a dominant discourse need not mean that Read More …

Entering the Conversation

In a comment on this post, use some piece of Gee’s “Discourse” theory to explain how using Gerald Graff’s and Cathy Birkenstein’s templates could “help your writing become more original and creative” (Graff and Birkenstein 11).  What would Gee say about how having pre-set templates empower you to be more creative as a thinker and writer? Read More …

Politics and Delpit’s Two Critiques of Gee

Remember our procedure for making text-to-text connections: Locate a passage from one text (Delpit’s Critique 1) Paraphrase it Find a related passage in another text (Gee’s discussion on p. 7 of how you can’t learn Discourses through overt instruction) Paraphrase it Use what would Author 1 say to Author 2 about a specific example drawn Read More …

Patchwriting as a Phase of Development

“Patchwriting” is the term writing researcher Rebecca Moore Howard (1993) uses to describe the incomplete paraphrase strategy that writers just emerging in a field often find themselves using to make it seem as if they are more knowledgeable than they are. It’s not just student writers who patchwrite.  Howard reports on the work of Miguel Read More …